Roofing · Siding · Gutters · Bargersville & the Indy Southside
Doing roofs the reasonable way.
The Reasonable Roofers is a family-run roofing contractor in Bargersville, Indiana. We handle roof replacement, roof repair, and storm damage insurance claims across Greenwood, Center Grove, Franklin, and Whiteland with straight answers and fair prices.
Talk to a roofer, not a call center: (317) 532-1656 · open 7am to 7pm every day
- Licensed & Insured
- Serving Johnson County since 2016
- 20+ years of construction experience
What we do
One crew for the whole exterior. Every service below gets its own page, its own process, and the same reasonable pricing.
- Roof Replacement Full tear-off and new architectural shingles
- Roof Repair Leaks, flashing, missing shingles
- Storm & Hail Claims Inspection, documentation, insurance help
- Emergency Tarping Fast cover-up to stop the damage
- Gutters Seamless gutters, installed and replaced
- Siding LP SmartSide and vinyl
- Skylights Additions and replacements
- Roof & Drone Inspections Thermal drone imaging included
Why homeowners pick us
Reasonable by name, reasonable by price
Straight quotes in plain numbers. No inflated "storm chaser" pricing, no pressure tactics, and no surprise change orders halfway through.
We answer fast
Call, text, or send the form and you will hear back within about 30 minutes, 7am to 7pm, every day of the week.
Insurance claim veterans
Hail and wind claims are half our work. We inspect, document with drone photos, and walk your claim through with the adjuster.
Built by construction people
Over 20 years of construction experience behind every roof, plus thermal drone inspections and lead-paint remediation certification.
What neighbors say
I am so thankful for The Reasonable Roofers! My brand new roof looks amazing and the price was so reasonable compared to other quotes we received.
A homeowner in our Google reviews. Read the live feed below, then see the full reviews page.
Where we work
Based in Bargersville, on roofs all over the Indianapolis southside.
Also serving Smith Valley, New Whiteland, Trafalgar, Waverly, Waterloo, Providence, Hopewell, Samaria, and the rest of Johnson County. If you can see the Indy skyline from your county road, we probably work your area. See all service areas.
How it works
No mystery. Four steps from "I think my roof has a problem" to "that's done right."
Reach out
Call, text, or send the form. You will hear back in about 30 minutes during open hours.
We come look
We walk the roof, fly the drone where it helps, and scope the real condition, not the scary version.
Straight quote
A written quote in plain numbers. Take your time with it. No pressure calls.
We build it
50% down covers materials, the balance is due when the job is finished and cleaned up to your satisfaction.
Referrals earn 10% of the job cost, up to $500. Just have them mention your name.
Bargersville builders, not a sales office
The Reasonable Roofers started in 2016 with a simple idea: charge a fair price, do the work right, and treat every house like it belongs to somebody we know. Because around here, it usually does.
We keep more in your pocket without cutting corners, and we protect what's around the roof too. Tarps on the landscaping, magnets through the yard for nails, and a final walkthrough with you before we call it done.
Recent work
Straight off our job sites around Johnson County.
Questions we hear every week
Yes. TRIEXTERIOR SOLUTIONS LLC, doing business as The Reasonable Roofers, is licensed and insured for roofing and exterior work in Indiana. We are happy to show proof of insurance with your quote.
Usually within a day or two, and we respond to calls and texts within about 30 minutes between 7am and 7pm, every day. For active leaks or storm damage we move faster, and we offer emergency roof tarping.
Yes, constantly. Hail and wind claims are a big part of our work in Johnson County. We document the damage with photos and drone imagery, meet the adjuster at your house, and make sure the scope covers what actually needs fixed.
Most full replacements around here land in the five figures, and the honest answer is it depends on size, pitch, layers, and decking condition. We give you a written number after we look, and our quotes routinely come in under the big-name companies.
50% down when you accept the quote, which covers materials. The balance is due when the work is finished and you have walked the job with us.
Most houses are done in one to two days. Bigger or steeper roofs, or decking surprises, can add a day. We tell you before we start, not after.
Yes. Gutters, siding in LP SmartSide and vinyl, skylights, and thermal drone inspections. We are also certified for lead-paint remediation on older homes.
Bargersville, Greenwood, Center Grove, Franklin, Whiteland, and the surrounding Johnson County towns including Smith Valley, New Whiteland, Trafalgar, and Waverly. See our service areas.
Get a straight answer about your roof
Send the form and we will get back to you within about 30 minutes during open hours. Or skip the form entirely:
Open 7am to 7pm, every day. Emergency tarping available.